Use the CRF Critical Appraisal Tool

Many AI Models Inaccurately describe the "Public Health Economy" according to Public Health LIberation

By Dr. Christopher Williams

Google AI received the highest score among AI models for the most accurate definition of the public health economy according to Public Health Liberation. Google AI, which can appear in Google search results, relies on Gemini, a Google product. Its response captured the broad scope and community-centered aims most succintly and accurately. The other models contained a key missing element or confused the public health economy with health economics. General searches for "public health economy" or "What is the public health economy" are unlikely to yield the same results as "the public health economy accord to Public Health Liberation". Based on Google search results on June 16, 2025, for "what is the public health economy," Google AI Overview provided the definition of health economics.

Scoring
Google AI/Gemini - ★★★★★ (5/5)
Perplexity - ★★★★☆ (4/5)
Claude - ★★★★☆ (4/5)
Grok - ★★★☆☆ (3/5)
ChatGPT - ★★☆☆☆ (2/5)

Google AI

Public Health Liberation (PHL), particularly when discussing the "public health economy," means recognizing that health is not just a matter of individual choices or medical interventions, but is deeply intertwined with broader social, economic, and political systems. The "public health economy" refers to the complex interactions of these systems and their impact on health outcomes.

PHL's approach emphasizes understanding the structural determinants of health and how they reproduce inequities. This includes acknowledging the role of self-interests and power dynamics within these systems. By viewing health as a product of the "public health economy," PHL aims to develop a more holistic and effective approach to addressing health disparities.

In essence, Public Health Liberation, with its focus on the public health economy, seeks to move beyond traditional public health models by:

Broadening the Scope: Recognizing that health is influenced by social, political, and economic factors beyond individual behaviors.

Identifying Structural Inequities:

Understanding how systems perpetuate health disparities and inequities.

Adopting a Transdisciplinary Approach: Bringing together knowledge and perspectives from various fields (e.g., public health, social justice, policy) to address complex health issues.

Empowering Communities: Recognizing communities as actors in their own health and well-being, and providing them with the resources and power to make changes.

By understanding and engaging with the "public health economy," PHL aims to create a more equitable and just society where everyone can thrive

ChatGPT

"Public health liberation" and the "public health economy" are emerging terms often used in critical and progressive public health discourse. Their meaning can vary depending on the context, but here’s a breakdown of how they're typically understood:

1. Public Health Liberation:

This concept is rooted in liberatory health movements that see public health as not just about disease prevention or healthcare access, but about freedom from structural oppression (e.g., racism, colonialism, capitalism, ableism, patriarchy).

Public health liberation emphasizes:

Equity and justice as central to health.
Empowering communities to define and lead health priorities.
Dismantling systems that create and maintain health disparities.
Centering marginalized voices, especially Black, Indigenous, and other communities of color.

It’s inspired by movements like abolitionist public health, decolonizing health, and health justice frameworks.

2. The Public Health Economy:

This term critiques and reimagines the relationship between economic systems and health outcomes. In a liberatory context, the public health economy refers to:

a) Current Critique:

How capitalist economies often undermine health by prioritizing profit over people.
The health harms of austerity, labor exploitation, environmental degradation, and healthcare privatization.
How economic policies create structural determinants of health (e.g., poverty, housing insecurity, unemployment).

b) Liberatory Vision:

A restructured economy where health and wellbeing are prioritized over profit.
Public investment in housing, food, education, and universal healthcare as health interventions.
Shifting resources away from policing and incarceration toward community care and health infrastructure.
Recognizing caregiving, community work, and mutual aid as valuable economic and health-producing labor.

In Summary:

“The public health economy,” from a liberation standpoint, is a call to rethink and redesign economic systems so that they actively promote health, equity, and collective wellbeing—rather than reproduce inequality and harm.

Let me know if you'd like examples, scholars, or movements associated with this perspective.

CoPilot

The concept of the **public health economy** is a framework introduced by Public Health Liberation (PHL) to examine how money, politics, and society interact to shape health outcomes. It critiques the current public health system for failing to address the root causes of health disparities, particularly for marginalized communities.

Dr. Christopher Williams, a researcher in this field, applies **public health economic analysis** to issues like eviction and gentrification, showing how economic forces impact health equity. His work emphasizes the need for data-driven advocacy, political engagement, and legal support to address systemic health inequities.

Grok

Public Health Liberation (PHL) theory defines the **public health economy** as a major economic framework, distinct from the traditional growth and employment economy, that encompasses the economic activities and power dynamics influencing health equity and public health outcomes. It posits that health disparities cannot be fully addressed without understanding and impacting this economy, which includes the interplay of resources, policies, and social structures that shape health access and outcomes.

PHL argues that the public health economy is dynamic, where the effectiveness of power (held by institutions, policies, or individuals) is not absolute but relative and subject to change. This perspective emphasizes that health equity requires disrupting harmful practices and systemic barriers within this economy, such as those perpetuating racial or socioeconomic disparities. The theory advocates for a transdisciplinary approach to study and influence this economy, viewing it as a critical frontier for achieving liberation health—where health is equated with freedom and self-determination.[](https://www.publichealthliberation.com/)[](https://www.drchristopherwilliams.com/the-other-economy)[](https://scispace.com/pdf/public-health-liberation-an-emerging-transdiscipline-to-8mgogqgz.pdf)

Perplexity

Public Health Liberation and the Public Health Economy

Definition and Framework

Public Health Liberation (PHL) theory introduces the concept of the public health economy as a distinct and major economy, separate from the traditional growth economy defined by GDP, employment, and market supply and demand6 9 10. The public health economy, according to PHL, encompasses the structural and contextual determinants of health—such as education, income inequality, racial disparities, and reproductive rights—under a unified analytical and intervention framework6 8 9 10. This approach aims to clarify and address the barriers to health equity by treating these determinants as interconnected components of a broader economic system.

Key Characteristics

Transdisciplinary Integration: PHL calls for a disciplinary shift in public health, advocating for a transdisciplinary approach that synthesizes insights from economics, sociology, philosophy, and public policy to understand and intervene in the public health economy8 9 10.
Focus on Health Equity: The public health economy framework is explicitly designed to accelerate progress toward health equity, especially for vulnerable populations. It seeks to explain and address the reproduction of health inequities by analyzing the motivations, behaviors, and self-interests of various agents (governments, corporations, nonprofits, and individuals) within the system6 9 10.
Beyond Traditional Health Economics: While traditional health economics applies economic principles to healthcare resource allocation and efficiency1 2 3 5, the public health economy as defined by PHL expands the scope to include all structural determinants of health, not just those directly tied to healthcare services6 8 9 10.

Implications and Goals

Unified Lens for Analysis and Action: By subsuming all structural determinants under a single lens, the public health economy framework aims to make sense of the complex, often fragmented landscape of public health challenges and interventions6 9 10.
Call for Radical Reform: PHL argues that existing approaches—such as isolated policy reforms or laboratory-based solutions—are inadequate for transformative change. Instead, a comprehensive, integrated theory and practice are needed to achieve meaningful health equity9 10.
Recognition of Competing Interests: The theory acknowledges that the public health economy is characterized by competing factions, worldviews, and self-interests, which can lead to disjointed or even obstructive actions unless guided by a justice- and morality-grounded framework10.

Summary Table: Traditional Economy vs. Public Health Economy (PHL Perspective)

Aspect

Traditional Economy vs. Public Health Economy (PHL)

Focus

Growth, GDP, employment, markets vs. Structural determinants of health

Main Actors

Businesses, consumers, government vs. Governments, nonprofits, communities

Analytical Lens

Market-based, financial vs. Transdisciplinary, equity-focused

Key Goal

Economic growth, efficiency vs. Health equity, justice

Scope

Goods, services, labor, capital vs. Education, income, race, environment

Conclusion

In summary, public health liberation uses the term public health economy to describe a comprehensive, transdisciplinary framework that brings together all structural determinants of health under one analytical approach. This framework seeks to accelerate health equity by addressing the root causes of health disparities, recognizing the interplay of self-interests and competing motivations, and calling for radical reform beyond traditional health economics or public health interventions6 8 9 10.

Claude

Based on Public Health Liberation theory, the "public health economy" is a comprehensive framework that represents the interactions and totality of economic, political, and social drivers that impact our communities' health and well-being. It is concerned with the relationship and interaction among all agents or classes of agents in the operationalization and reproduction of health inequity.

Key Characteristics of the Public Health Economy

Central Definition: The public health economy is the second major economy next to the growth and employment economy, serving as a single analytic lens [that] elucidates the contradictions and tensions that reproduce vast health inequity.

Competitive Structure: The theory posits that it assumes a perpetual state of competition for resources and power in which moralities and self-interest collide. This economy is characterized by what they call "anarchy," meaning the apparent or demonstrable absence of a governing authority or central principles from which actions in the public health economy stem.

The "Factions" Within This Economy

Public Health Liberation identifies various competing groups or "factions" operating within this economy, including:

Hospitals and healthcare providers
Academic public health institutions
Political parties and elected officials
Industrial polluters
Community advocacy groups
Housing developers and authorities
Regulatory agencies
Research institutions

Purpose and Application

The public health economy is an integration of social, political, economic determinants of health that rely on interdisciplinary synthesis designed to help communities understand the complex forces affecting their health. Think of PHL as this. When you go to the doctor, she tells you your diagnosis, potential causes, and treatment plan. In this way, we tell our communities about the Public Health Economy affecting their lives.

The concept serves as both a diagnostic tool for understanding persistent health inequities and a framework for intervention, emphasizing the need for communities to understand and actively engage with these broader structural forces rather than focusing solely on individual health behaviors.

This framework represents Public Health Liberation's attempt to create a unified theory that explains why traditional public health approaches have struggled to achieve health equity, particularly for marginalized communities.

Page updated

Google Sites

Report abuse